Family wealth / Lifetime gifting
Who Can Access a Spousal Lifetime Access Trust?
Robin wants to set aside money for the children but worries about paying for the family home if Casey dies first. In a spousal lifetime access trust (SLAT), Robin can make a permanent gift for the family. Under this couple’s terms, Casey can ask the trustee for money, and the trustee decides whether to pay. Robin would have to rely on income and assets outside the trust.
Explore who can access the moneyWhat would Robin be giving up?
Robin owns a business. Casey is a physician. Their children are young, and Casey’s income helps pay for the home where they hope to raise them. Robin has $6 million in separately owned liquid investments and is considering putting $2 million into a trust for the family.
On the day of the gift, Robin would keep $4 million in investments. An independent trustee would manage the other $2 million under written instructions naming Casey as the first beneficiary. The family could still see $6 million on two statements, but Robin could no longer take the gift back.
The couple likes the idea of giving those assets time to grow for their children. Before signing, they want to know which bills the trust could pay along the way.
What can Casey ask the trustee to pay for?
Suppose Casey asks the trustee to pay a medical bill. A few months later, Casey asks for money for a photography trip. Could the trustee approve both? In this family’s trust, yes. Robin gave the independent trustee broad discretion to use trust income or principal for Casey’s benefit. The trip can qualify even though it is entirely optional.
Casey can explain what the trip would cost and why it matters. The trustee decides whether to pay and how much, acting in good faith under the trust’s terms and considering the interests of the beneficiaries. A payment for Casey’s own expenses can ease the household budget. Casey has no automatic right to a payment, and Robin has no right to direct one or take the money back.
Another family might limit payments to health, education, maintenance or support. That limit comes from how the trust is written. Robin chose to make the children eligible for payments only after Casey dies. In the example below, change which spouse dies first to see who can ask for money.
Who can use the trust after a spouse dies?
Robin funds the trust. Casey is the beneficiary spouse. An independent trustee decides on distributions.- Gift held in trust at funding
- $2,000,000
- Kept in Robin’s name at funding
- $4,000,000
What changes when the first spouse dies?
If Casey dies first, the household loses Casey’s earnings and any help from trust payments for Casey’s ongoing needs. The trustee now holds the money for the children and can consider distributions for their own needs. Robin gains no new rights to trust money. For the house payments Robin worries about, the assets outside the trust would have to do the work.
If Robin dies first, Casey can still ask the trustee for distributions for life. Casey has no automatic right to withdraw the whole balance. To find out whether Casey would also receive Robin’s separate assets, the couple would need to check how those assets are titled, the beneficiary arrangements, the estate plan and applicable law.
Before Robin funds the trust, the couple can also ask what would happen after a divorce. Does the document name Casey personally or make eligibility depend on being married to Robin? Counsel can explain the effect under state law.
Would the gift still work on one income?
Start with Robin’s budget if Casey died. Suppose Robin would need $210,000 a year and could count on $90,000 of after-tax income. That leaves $120,000 to draw from savings in the first year. If Robin makes the $2 million gift and has $4 million left, the draw is 3% of the remaining portfolio. A $3 million gift would leave $3 million and raise that same first-year draw to 4%.
Those percentages measure the first year. To see how long the money might last, Robin would also need to allow for taxes on withdrawals, inflation, care costs, uneven business income and weak investment returns. Then run Casey’s budget assuming Robin dies first. Count the outside assets Casey would actually inherit, and check who receives any insurance proceeds or survivor benefits and when.
If either budget depends on the trustee approving a regular payment, the couple can try a smaller gift. They could cover a child’s tuition now and leave a larger transfer until they know how much they can spare.
How would Robin report the gift?
Once the couple has chosen a possible amount, Robin’s advisers can work through the taxes. In this example Robin has enough unused federal gift and estate tax exemption to cover the taxable gift. Robin still reports it on the federal gift tax return, Form 709. Casey’s interest lasts only for life, the trustee decides whether to pay, and the children have the remaining interest. Those terms do not qualify for the gift tax marital deduction.
If Robin makes a completed gift and the trust assets stay outside Robin’s federal gross estate, those assets and their later growth can pass outside the estate for federal estate tax purposes. A private arrangement for Robin to keep enjoying the assets, or trust payments that satisfy Robin’s legal support obligations, could bring some or all of them back into the estate tax calculation.
Income tax is a separate cost for the household budget. If Robin is treated as the trust owner for federal income tax during life, Robin may owe tax on the trust’s earnings even in a year when the trustee makes no distribution.
Could Casey create a second trust for Robin?
Having seen what Robin gives up, Casey might offer to put separate assets into another trust for Robin. That would make each spouse a beneficiary of a trust funded by the other. It also raises a question under the federal reciprocal trust doctrine.
In United States v. Estate of Grace, the Supreme Court considered whether the trusts were interrelated and whether, to the extent of their mutual value, each spouse ended up in approximately the same economic position as if they had created a trust for their own lifetime benefit. If both conditions hold, assets may be included in a donor’s federal gross estate even if neither spouse intended to avoid tax.
Signing on different dates alone does not resolve the issue. Before drafting a second trust, have counsel ask each spouse what they own, whom they want to benefit and what powers each would hold.
What if the trustee buys life insurance?
Another choice concerns the assets inside Robin’s original trust. Suppose the trust meets the insurer’s private offering requirements and Robin qualifies for coverage. The trustee holds some of the $2 million in cash and uses part of the gift to pay premiums on a private placement life insurance (PPLI) policy on Robin’s life. The policy can build cash value during Robin’s life and pay a death benefit when Robin dies. The trustee owns the policy on behalf of the trust, and the trust is named to receive the death benefit.
Return to Casey’s medical bill. The trustee could pay it with available trust cash. If the policy has enough loan value, the trustee could instead borrow against the policy and decide separately whether to approve a distribution for Casey. The trust owes the insurer. Casey’s right is to request a distribution. The policy gives Robin no borrowing or withdrawal right.
If Robin dies first while the policy is in force, the insurer pays the trust. Any outstanding loan and interest reduce the payout. Casey can still request distributions. If Casey dies first, the policy on Robin pays no death benefit at that point. The children become eligible under the trust terms, and the trustee still manages the policy and its loan.
What if the trustee wants to leave more of the insurance payout intact? Suppose the trust owes the insurer $100,000, including interest. The trustee can repay the loan with $100,000 the trust already holds. The trust spends that cash today and removes the loan deduction from the eventual death benefit, assuming the policy stays in force. The trustee is using trust assets to pay trust debt. If Robin instead gives the trust the money or pays its debt without reimbursement, that payment can be a new gift.
Life insurance death benefits generally qualify for a federal income tax exclusion under §101, subject to exceptions. Federal estate tax follows different rules. Under §2042, questions include whether proceeds are payable to Robin’s estate and whether Robin retained ownership rights over the policy.
What would the policy cost the family?
Ask the insurer to show how much the trust would pay in premiums, policy charges, investment fees and interest if it borrowed. Compare that with keeping the investments directly in the trust. The quoted loan rate is only part of the cost. The contract also determines what the insurer credits on the assets backing the loan. Weak returns, surrender charges or unpaid interest can leave less for the children and increase the risk that the policy will lapse.
The possible tax benefit is that gains in a qualifying variable life policy can accumulate without annual federal income tax to the policyholder. The policy must meet federal life insurance rules (§7702), the separate account must satisfy investment diversification rules (§817(h)), and the policyholder must respect limits on control over the investments. Too much control can make the policyholder responsible for tax on the investment income.
Borrowing has its own tax rules. A loan from a qualifying policy that stays in force generally creates no immediate federal income tax if the policy is not a modified endowment contract (MEC). Paying premiums too quickly can cause the policy to fail the seven-pay test under §7702A and become a MEC. A loan from a MEC generally counts as a distribution under §72, taxable first to the extent of earnings. A taxable amount can also face a 10% additional tax before age 59½, subject to exceptions. With a trust as owner, ask whose age and tax status apply.
Even a loan that initially produced no income tax can have consequences later. If the policy lapses or is surrendered, settling the loan can produce taxable gain above the policy’s tax basis even when the trust receives little or no cash.
Use the PPLI Projection Calculator to compare hypothetical policy values and costs. Ask the insurer for a policy illustration before using those figures in your plan.
How far should this gift reach?
If Robin and Casey want the trustee to hold assets for grandchildren as well as children, bring that goal to counsel before funding. Federal generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax can apply when trust assets pass to grandchildren or other skip persons. With sufficient available GST exemption and an effective allocation, a trust can be fully exempt from GST tax. Check how much exemption Robin has, whether allocation is automatic or requires an election or affirmative allocation on Form 709, and when the allocation can take effect.
How long a trust can last under its governing law is a separate question from which states can tax its income. South Dakota has abolished the common-law rule against perpetuities and imposes no state personal income tax. If a trust administered there later makes a distribution that carries taxable income to a child living in New York, the child may have to report that income on a New York return. New York may also treat a trust funded by a New York domiciliary as a resident trust. Even when that trust qualifies for exemption from New York income tax, the trustee still has a state filing obligation, and certain distributions of accumulated income can be taxable to New York resident beneficiaries.
Robin and Casey can come back to the number that started the discussion. If the household lost Casey’s income tomorrow, could Robin meet the $120,000 annual gap from the accounts left outside the trust? If the roles were reversed, could Casey stay in the home? Their answers help them decide whether to give the full $2 million now, give less or wait.
Sources and further reading
This article discusses U.S. federal planning concepts. Review the rules for the intended gift year and your circumstances with your tax and legal advisers.
- Internal Revenue Code §6019 · Gift tax returns
- Internal Revenue Code §2523 · Gifts to a spouse
- Treasury Regulation §25.2511-2 · When a gift is complete
- Internal Revenue Code §2036 · Retained interests and estate inclusion
- IRS · Form 709 gift tax reporting instructions
- Treasury Regulation §20.2036-1 · Retained use and support obligations
- Congressional Research Service · Spousal lifetime access trusts and federal taxes
- Oregon Revised Statutes §130.715 · An example of state law governing trustee discretion
- Internal Revenue Code §677 · Trust income for the grantor or spouse
- U.S. Supreme Court · United States v. Estate of Grace (1969)
- Internal Revenue Code §7702 · Life insurance qualification
- Internal Revenue Code §817(h) · Variable policy diversification
- IRS Revenue Ruling 2003-91 · Investor control
- Internal Revenue Code §7702A · Modified endowment contracts
- Internal Revenue Code §72 · Policy distributions and loans
- Prudential · Example of purchaser qualifications for a trust-owned PPLI policy
- SEC filing · Variable life prospectus example of loan costs and lapse risk
- SEC Investor.gov · Variable life insurance and policy loans
- Internal Revenue Code §2511 · Direct and indirect gifts
- Internal Revenue Code §101 · Federal income tax on death benefits
- Internal Revenue Code §2042 · Life insurance in the gross estate
- Internal Revenue Code §2632 · Allocation of GST exemption
- Internal Revenue Code §2642 · GST inclusion ratio and timing
- South Dakota Codified Law §43-5-8 · Rule against perpetuities
- South Dakota Department of Revenue · State income tax
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance · Income tax for New York residents
- New York Tax Law §605 · Resident trust definition and exemption
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance · Trust filing and accumulation distributions
- U.S. Supreme Court · North Carolina Department of Revenue v. Kaestner (2019)