Wealth transfer / Investing for the next generation
How a GRAT Can Move Future Growth to Your Family
Put $10 million of stock into a grantor retained annuity trust (GRAT), and the trust pays you on a schedule for a set number of years. While it is treated as your grantor trust for federal income tax purposes, you report its income on your own return. Your children can receive what remains after the last payment. How much reaches them depends on when the stock gains value and when the payments come due.
Compare when the gains arriveHow the trust works while you receive payments
You fund the GRAT with $10 million of shares and retain the right to scheduled payments, called an annuity. In this example, the GRAT is treated as your grantor trust during the annuity term. You report its taxable income, including dividends and realized gains, on your own federal income tax return and are responsible for the tax. You also serve as trustee and direct the investments within the terms of the trust and your fiduciary duties. Your children can receive what is left after the final payment. That remainder can be zero.
Take a two-year GRAT that owes you about $5,378,049 at the end of each year. Suppose the shares rise 24% in year one. As trustee, you make the first payment, leaving about $7,021,951 invested in the trust. If those shares then rise 18%, you can make the second payment and distribute about $2,907,854 to your children. This example assumes you survive both years and excludes taxes and fees.
Why can a trust funded with $10 million use little or none of your lifetime gift tax exemption? For federal gift tax purposes, you generally subtract the present value of your qualifying annuity from the fair market value of the shares when you fund the trust. The IRS publishes a monthly valuation rate under Section 7520 for this calculation. At an illustrative 5%, those two scheduled payments are worth about $10 million on the funding date. This is a “zeroed-out” GRAT. Document the valuation and disclose the transfer on Form 709 even if the calculated gift is zero or nominal.
The example values the annuity for the full two years. It assumes the trust terms direct any remaining scheduled payments to your estate if you die during that period.
How much more would your children keep?
Follow the same shares to the end of year two. If you keep all the shares yourself, they grow to $14,632,000. With the GRAT, suppose you reinvest the first annuity payment in the same stock. When the final payment arrives, you hold about $11,724,146 and your children hold the other $2,907,854. The family owns the same amount either way. Who owns it matters when the estate tax comes due.
Suppose you die just after the term ends and the remainder passes to your children. You leave them the rest of your estate. You have $10 million of other net assets and $15 million of federal estate tax exclusion available at death. Both estates exceed that exclusion. Moving the remainder to your children during your lifetime reduces the federal estate tax by about $1.16 million at the 40% marginal rate. The annuity payments you kept still count in your estate.
If your estate would already fall below your available exclusion, the same GRAT could transfer growth to your children with no federal estate tax savings. This example assumes a zeroed-out gift, no state estate tax, and no fees or income taxes. State rules and the income tax basis of the shares can also affect what your children ultimately keep.
| At the end of year two | Keep the shares | Use the GRAT |
|---|---|---|
| Assets in your estate | $24,632,000 | $21,724,146 |
| Assets already with children | $0 | $2,907,854 |
| Federal estate tax | $3,852,800 | $2,689,659 |
| Total for children | $20,779,200 | $21,942,341 |
When should your children receive the remainder?
Now give the same stock six years. With one six-year GRAT, you receive payments throughout the term and any remainder goes to your children at the end of year six. With three successive two-year GRATs, the first can deliver a remainder at the end of year two. In this rolling example, you invest both payments and use those proceeds to fund a new trust when each term ends. Each new trust has its own payment schedule and uses the valuation rate for its funding month.
Try “Early gains” and set the comparison to year two. The shorter trust has already transferred about $2,907,854 to your children. If they keep those shares, later gains and losses affect what the shares are worth to them. Switch to “Late gains” and look at year five. The six-year trust owes about $1,970,175 and uses its last $821,732 to pay what it can. The year-six recovery happens after the trust runs out of shares. The stock earned the same returns in a different order. The payment dates changed who still held it when it rose.
Where does the growth land?
Asset values after year 6
One six-year GRAT
- Held by beneficiaries
- $2,267,984
- Held by donor
- $10,791,121
- Inside an active GRAT
- $0
Three successive two-year GRATs
- Held by beneficiaries
- $2,645,367
- Held by donor
- $10,413,738
- Inside an active GRAT
- $0
Under these assumptions, the successive two-year trusts left beneficiaries with $377,383 more at the end of year six.
How this comparison works
Each starting trust uses an illustrative 5% valuation rate and a level year-end annuity with a present value equal to the contribution. Each year’s annuity is paid from available trust assets.
All three pools earn the displayed investment returns. At each two-year term’s end, any remainder passes to beneficiaries. At the start of years three and five the donor uses all accumulated annuity proceeds to fund a new trust at the selected rate. Each snapshot shows holdings after payments and before the next trust is funded.
All three paths rearrange the same six annual returns. Both structures therefore end with the same total family wealth before costs and taxes. The exhibit tracks who holds it, assuming the donor survives and there is no spending, tax or trust expense. Dollar figures are rounded.
Can a GRAT still work when interest rates are high?
The Section 7520 valuation rate helps set the payments when you fund a GRAT. For a new two-year, $10 million GRAT with equal year-end payments and a zeroed-out gift, a hypothetical rate of 3% requires about $5,226,108 a year. At 7% it takes about $5,530,918. If you receive those payments in shares at the same price, the higher payment takes more shares out of the trust. In this example, a steady annual return above the starting valuation rate would leave a remainder before costs.
A longer GRAT keeps the payment schedule set at funding. If valuation rates rise, that can favor the longer term. Each new two-year trust gives you another chance to capture a strong period for the stock, and a lower rate when you start the next trust can help. The stock could also disappoint across every term. Consider how many years you have and how much of each payment you can afford to reinvest.
Compare year six under “Uneven gains.” At a 5% rate for later trusts, the children hold about $668,098 from the six-year GRAT and $582,992 from the successive two-year trusts. Changing the rate for later trusts from 3% to 7% leaves the children with the same amount under the rolling strategy because both later trusts run out of assets at either rate. Switch to “Early gains” and the results change with the rate. Estimating how likely either outcome is would require assumptions about investment returns, volatility, costs and reinvestment.
How much should come out in the first year?
The examples so far pay the same amount each year. You can also set up the GRAT with a smaller first payment and larger payments later. This escalating annuity lets more shares stay in the trust after the first payment, where they can gain or lose value. Under the qualified annuity rules, each year’s payment can increase by up to 20% over the preceding year’s payment. For the same $10 million contribution at 5%, an escalating two-year annuity could pay $4,900,000 in year one and $5,880,000 in year two. Both schedules have the same present value at funding.
For a founder holding private shares, the larger second payment may come due before a planned company sale closes. Could the trustee make it with cash on hand or by transferring properly valued shares? A promise to pay later does not satisfy the annuity.
After a gain, should the stock stay in the trust?
Return to the two-year GRAT with two $5,378,049 payments. This time imagine $10 million of Microsoft shares rises 15% by the first payment date. When you set up the trust, you can separately reserve a properly structured substitution power in your personal capacity. If you reserved that power, you can exchange $11.5 million of your own cash for the shares immediately before that payment, assuming that is their fair market value at the time. As trustee, you then decide how to invest the cash under the trust terms and your fiduciary duties. You hold the shares and will receive their next gain or bear their next loss.
If the cash earns nothing, it covers both annuity payments and leaves about $743,902 for the children. What if you keep the stock in the trust, sell or distribute enough shares to make the first payment, and hold the rest for year two? A 20% decline leaves nothing for the children after paying as much of the annuity as the trust can afford. A 20% gain leaves about $1,968,293. These figures use the same hypothetical 5% valuation rate, assume you survive the term and exclude taxes and fees.
The trustee has a duty to confirm the values and ensure the substitution power cannot shift benefits among beneficiaries. When you serve as trustee, have counsel address who will verify the exchange and how conflicts will be handled. A properly executed exchange of equivalent values transfers no additional gift value and uses no additional gift tax exemption. While you are treated as the owner of the entire trust for federal income tax purposes, the exchange generally does not trigger recognition of gain or reset the shares’ tax basis. That basis matters when you sell the shares.
Before exchanging the shares, set aside the $11.5 million the swap requires. What cash would you still have outside the trust to pay the income tax you owe on its earnings? Paying your own tax liability from those resources can leave more invested for the family without an additional gift.
Which generation do you want to help?
A GRAT often fits best when parents want future growth to reach their children. Parents can retain scheduled payments while giving their children a chance to receive any growth left after those payments. The term needs to fit both the investment and the parent’s circumstances. If you die during the annuity term, some or all of the trust’s remaining assets can enter your federal gross estate. A two-year term gives each trust a chance to finish sooner. Starting another trust adds a new schedule, valuation and potential fees, and you can still have a trust in progress when you die.
A GRAT can also leave assets to grandchildren or later generations. Sheltering that transfer from generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax may require allocating some of your available GST exemption. In a typical GRAT, the allocation takes effect when the estate tax inclusion period ends, usually at the end of the annuity term if you survive it. A timely allocation generally uses the value at that point, so growth during the term can mean using more GST exemption than you expected.
If your main goal is to benefit grandchildren and later generations, a common alternative is a direct gift to a separate multigenerational trust with available GST exemption allocated at funding. If the allocation can take effect then, it generally uses the gift tax value at funding. That can be a more efficient use of GST exemption for assets you expect to appreciate.
Choose a holding you could commit and put the payment dates on your calendar. How much of each payment would you keep for spending? How much could you afford to put into another trust? Those answers, together with whom you want to benefit, give your advisers a concrete choice of terms to evaluate.
Model your own contribution in the free GRAT calculatorSources and further reading
This article discusses U.S. federal planning concepts. Review the rules for the intended gift year and your circumstances with your tax and legal advisers.
- IRS overview of the federal estate tax and exclusion
- IRS Form 706 instructions and federal estate tax rate schedule
- Treasury regulations on valuing retained interests
- IRS instructions for Form 709 · Gift reporting and valuation
- IRS Notice 2003-72 on valuing a GRAT annuity
- IRS monthly Section 7520 rates
- Treasury rules for qualified annuity interests
- IRS Revenue Ruling 2008-22 on substitution powers
- Internal Revenue Code Section 2512 on gift valuation
- IRS discussion of Revenue Ruling 85-13 and grantor ownership
- Internal Revenue Code Section 671 on reporting grantor trust income
- IRS explanation of grantor retained annuity trusts
- IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-64 on grantor income tax payments
- Treasury rules for estate inclusion of retained interests
- Treasury rules for allocation of GST exemption
- Internal Revenue Code Section 2642 on GST exemption timing and valuation