Charitable planning / Concentrated stock

Can a Charitable Remainder Trust Help You Diversify Concentrated Stock?

A final bonus is coming, one stock accounts for much of your wealth, and you already plan to give to charity. This may be the year to diversify and put that gift in place. Follow $10 million of shares through a sale, a direct gift and a charitable remainder trust to see how much the family can keep, when the charity gets paid and what the deduction is worth today.

Compare selling, giving shares and funding a CRT

A final bonus, $10 million in one stock, and a scholarship promise

A retiring executive holds $10 million of publicly traded shares she bought years ago for $2 million. Her final bonus will lift her income well above what she expects in retirement. She wants to endow scholarships at her university. She also wants the flexibility to spend some of what those shares are worth.

If she sells everything personally, the gain is $8 million. At an assumed federal rate of 23.8%, the sale costs $1.904 million in tax and leaves $8.096 million she can diversify or spend. If the university needs funds now, she can give it shares directly before a sale. The university can put the gift to work immediately, and she can sell as much of her remaining position as she chooses.

A charitable remainder trust (CRT) gives her a third choice. She irrevocably transfers shares to a qualifying trust, receives payments for a period she sets in advance, and commits the balance to the university. The trust can generally sell and diversify the full $10 million before expenses without paying federal capital gains tax on the sale. It carries over her basis and tracks the gain for future payments. If a sale is already practically certain before the transfer, she may owe the tax personally. Counsel should review any pending deal before she commits.

Would you build a 30-year family plan around NVIDIA?

Suppose the shares are NVIDIA and represent $10 million of a $25 million portfolio. The family can believe in the business and still have too much riding on a single outcome. If the shares fell by half while everything else held its value, the portfolio would lose $5 million, or 20% of everything the family has invested. Which plans would the family have to change? If the shares doubled instead, how much of that upside would the family want to keep?

Being a leader in AI chips and being the world’s largest listed company by market value are different achievements. NVIDIA itself identifies customers developing competing technology as a risk. In a study of the ten largest listed companies worldwide by market value, Research Affiliates found that only Apple and Microsoft appeared in both its 2010 and 2021 lists. None of the companies on its 1990 list appeared in its 2021 top ten. A company can lose its rank while its shares still make money.

Those snapshots give us no reliable percentage chance that NVIDIA will lead in 20 or 30 years. The family can make a decision today by setting aside enough diversified assets for retirement, deciding what to give, and choosing a remaining stake it could afford to hold through a bad decade. Both a personal sale and a sale inside a CRT reduce single-stock exposure when the proceeds are diversified.

Explore ways to reduce a concentrated stock position

Can she manage the trust herself and still receive income?

In this example she serves as trustee herself. With publicly traded shares and appropriate trust terms, the donor can manage the sale and reinvestment in that role. The trust owns the assets. She must follow the payout formula, keep records, file the trust’s return and protect the university’s interest. She cannot take extra principal for herself. She can hire help with investing, administration and tax reporting.

Some assets and powers change that answer. If a CRT holds an unmarketable asset, federal rules generally require an independent trustee to perform the valuations or a current qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser. Counsel should check the trust powers and governing law before she agrees to serve.

A charitable remainder annuity trust (CRAT) promises a fixed dollar payment. She chooses a standard charitable remainder unitrust (CRUT), which pays a percentage of the assets revalued annually. A 5% payout on a $10 million valuation is $500,000 for a full year. If the next valuation is $8 million, the payment falls to $400,000. Her household budget has to work at the lower figure too.

What does the 10% minimum actually buy the charity?

The minimum is tested when she contributes the shares. The value today of the charity’s future interest must be at least 10% of the amount she contributes, or $1 million on this gift. A CRUT applies the test to each contribution. That test does not guarantee a $1 million payment. The university receives the actual balance when the payments end. That balance can be worth more or less than the original valuation.

Compare two 20-year designs using the same federal valuation rate of 6.2%. An 11.5% annual payout puts the charitable interest just above the minimum, at about $1.01 million, or 10.10%. Reducing the payout to 5% raises that initial interest to about $3.81 million, or 38.12%. She gives up some annual income in exchange for a larger charitable commitment and a larger potential deduction. The exhibit also lets her shorten the term to ten years and see what changes.

Federal rules generally allow payouts from 5% to 50% and either a term of up to 20 years or payments for qualifying lives. The payout must still pass the remainder test. Fixed annuity payments for life raise a separate question about exhausting the trust. Counsel can evaluate the IRS provision that ends those payments early to preserve funds for charity.

Why might the final bonus year be the right year to give?

If she itemizes, she can potentially deduct the present value of the university’s interest in the funding year, even though the university may wait 20 years for the money. The deduction reduces taxable income. Its value to the family is the change in her tax bill.

Take the near-minimum design. Her other income in the bonus year is $20 million. With no other charitable gifts, the 2026 floor of 0.5% of her contribution base absorbs $100,000. About $910,000 of the initial $1.01 million interest is available as a current charitable deduction before the overall limit on itemized deductions. Under the exhibit’s federal assumptions the estimated reduction in her tax bill is about $319,000. A direct gift of shares can also generate a deduction in the bonus year.

Now suppose she waits until retirement and has $1 million of other income. For this gift of long-held shares with the remainder paid outright to a qualifying public charity, the example applies a 30% income limit and a $5,000 floor. The current deduction falls to $295,000 and the estimated tax savings to about $103,000. Moving the same gift into the bonus year is worth about $215,000 more in immediate federal tax savings under these assumptions. Different assets or charities can change the deduction. An eligible excess over the income limit can generally carry forward up to five more years. The floor has its own carryforward rules, and a future deduction is valuable only if she can use it.

What reaches the family, and what reaches the university?

The sale inside the trust defers the built-in gain. Her payments draw first on ordinary income, then capital gains, other income such as tax-exempt interest, and finally principal. Short-term gains generally come before long-term gains within the capital gains tier and are taxed at ordinary rates. The mix matters. If she reinvests in private credit that generates enough taxable interest to cover a payment, the whole payment may be taxed at ordinary rates even though she originally contributed long-held stock.

She reports the payment’s tax character from Schedule K-1. Receiving a payment or serving as trustee does not by itself make the whole trust hers for income tax purposes. A qualifying CRT can owe a separate excise tax equal to its unrelated business taxable income.

Compare the family’s after-tax wealth at the same date under each choice. Selling and keeping all the proceeds answers how much the family could retain if it made no gift. Giving a smaller block of shares to the university now and selling the rest shows how much she could keep if she funded a similar charitable outcome without a trust. In the illustration, the university invests the early gift so the comparison can show both balances at year 20.

Four ways to use the same $10 million in stock
Each path starts with $10M of long-held publicly traded shares and $2M of cost basis. Change the trust design, the donor’s income in the gift year or the investment return.

The CRUT deduction at funding

Actuarial remainder value
$1,010,43710.104% of the shares’ value
Deduction usable this year
$910,437Before the overall itemized deduction limit
Estimated federal tax savings
$318,653Invested in the family account
The statutory minimum actuarial remainder is 10%. The trust starts with $10M to invest. A personal sale leaves $8,096,000 after $1,904,000 of assumed federal sale tax.

Where the money is after 20 years

These projections use the same constant return for all four paths. Family balances include reinvested after-tax proceeds and payments, plus any modeled funding-year tax savings. Charity balances assume the charity invests its gift after receipt and makes no withdrawals.
Stock decisionFamily
Year 20
Charity
Year 20
Fund the CRUT20-year term, 11.5% payout$16.14M$2.75MReceives in year 20
Sell all sharesKeep the net proceeds$17.45M$0No gift
Give some sharesSell the rest$16.45M$2.75M$899,121 today
Give all shares outrightFamily balance comes from tax savings$4.45M$30.59M$10M today
At 6% gross, the CRUT leaves the family $313,153 less than giving some shares and selling the rest.The partial gift is sized to match the trust’s year-20 charity balance at 6%. Change the return to see both projections move while the upfront gift stays fixed.
Gross trust payments run from $1,150,000 in year 1 to $337,405 in year 20 in this projection. An outright gift gives the charity control and spending access today. The trust sets the payment formula and the date charity receives the balance. Market returns affect the dollars available.
Funding-year tax and cash by path

Fund the CRUT

Gift-year adjusted gross income
$20,000,000
Personal proceeds after sale tax
$0
Federal sale tax before gift benefit
$0
Potential charitable deduction
$1,010,437
Current-year charitable deduction
$910,437
Estimated federal tax savings
$318,653

Sell all shares

Gift-year adjusted gross income
$28,000,000
Personal proceeds after sale tax
$8,096,000
Federal sale tax before gift benefit
$1,904,000
Potential charitable deduction
$0
Current-year charitable deduction
$0
Estimated federal tax savings
$0

Give some shares

Gift-year adjusted gross income
$27,280,703
Personal proceeds after sale tax
$7,368,072
Federal sale tax before gift benefit
$1,732,807
Potential charitable deduction
$899,121
Current-year charitable deduction
$762,717
Estimated federal tax savings
$266,951

Give all shares outright

Gift-year adjusted gross income
$20,000,000
Personal proceeds after sale tax
$0
Federal sale tax before gift benefit
$0
Potential charitable deduction
$10,000,000
Current-year charitable deduction
$5,900,000
Estimated federal tax savings
$2,065,000
The trust path also incurs $3,647,904 of projected beneficiary taxes and $869,929 of trust-level fees over the term. Both are already reflected in the year-20 balances.
How the comparison is calculated
Assumes a year-end 2026 transfer before a sale becomes practically certain. The standard charitable remainder unitrust (CRUT) pays its remainder outright to a qualifying public charity. Using the elected November 2026 §7520 rate of 6.2%, the model values full-year payments made at year-end on beginning-of-year balances. The initial stub period is treated as negligible.
The current-year charitable deduction reflects the 30% contribution-base limit and the 2026 0.5% floor. It is shown before the overall itemized deduction limit, which the estimated tax savings include. Personal sales increase adjusted gross income by the gain they realize. The funding-year estimate assumes a single filer, the selected amount of ordinary income, $25,000 of other itemized deductions, and ordinary and long-term capital-gain brackets after the overall itemized deduction limitation. Carryforwards may provide later value and are excluded. The funding-year estimate excludes AMT, transaction and setup costs, state and local taxes, and other individual tax factors.
The same portfolio earns the selected gross return in all paths. Portfolio costs are 0.25% annually, with an extra 0.50% for trust administration. The model realizes 40% of investment earnings as ordinary income and 60% as long-term capital gains each year. It assumes 23.8% tax on personal sale gains and applies 40.8% to ordinary investment income and 23.8% to long-term gains in projected years, including 3.8% net investment income tax.
The trust diversifies after sale, with no immediate federal gain tax inside the trust under the assumptions. Distributions carry out ordinary income first, then accumulated long-term gains, then principal. The model assumes zero other income and no unrelated business taxable income inside the trust, and allocates fees to principal. All balances are illustrative nominal dollars. Constant returns omit the timing of gains and losses.

Which route would this family actually choose?

Start with the base case in the exhibit. The personal sale leaves the family about $17.45 million at year 20 and pays nothing to charity. The near-minimum CRUT leaves about $16.14 million for the family and $2.75 million for the university. Giving about $899,000 of shares outright today and selling the rest funds the same projected $2.75 million for the university at year 20 and leaves about $16.45 million for the family. All three assume a 6% gross return and reinvestment. Selling all the shares leaves the family with the most money in each return scenario shown. The comparison with a direct gift is closer. At 10% growth, the CRUT overtakes the fixed partial gift for both the family and the university. At 2%, it trails on both. These are scenarios. Estimating the odds for a particular family would require assumptions about the likelihood and timing of returns, its spending and the deductions it can use.

The trust earns its place if the family values the combination of an immediate sale, an income stream and a binding commitment to philanthropy. It also gives the next generation a role. While the trust is paying her, she and her children can meet with the university to agree on a scholarship purpose and learn how awards will be made. Once the endowment is funded, the children can review award reports with the university. A direct gift can support the same family involvement and start those scholarships sooner. Another family might choose a qualified family foundation or a donor-advised fund sponsor as the charitable recipient. At a donor-advised fund, family members can recommend grants and the sponsor has legal control.

If students need scholarships this year, a direct gift of appreciated shares gets funds to them sooner. If the family needs ready access to the original capital, selling personally preserves that flexibility. Before the bonus year ends, bring the stock basis, expected income, retirement budget and charitable timetable to your advisers. Ask them to compare those three outcomes using your numbers.

Sources and further reading

This article discusses U.S. federal planning concepts. Review the rules for the intended gift year and your circumstances with your tax and legal advisers.

Altar Rock / Connect your plan

What could your high-income year do for your family and your charity?

Bring your stock lots and this year’s expected income. Altar Rock can work with your tax and legal advisers to compare the near-term tax bill, what you can spend, and when your charity receives its gift.